Saturday, January 15, 2005

Breyer v. Scalia on Foreign Law and Constitutional Interpretation

As Chris noted, Justice Breyer and Scalia engaged in an unusual public "conversation" about the use of foreign law in constitutional interpretation last Thursday. The transcript has been posted here (via how appealing ). This exchange has already been the subject of numerous posts in the blogosphere here and here. I don't have much more to add except to observe that Justice Breyer's defense is essentially that since foreign law is not binding, it can't really be that bad (and might well be helpful) for constitutional interpretation. This is an attractive position, perhaps, but it is useful to compare Justice Breyer's defense with Justice Scalia's approach, which provides a theory of constitutional interpretation which coherently explains why foreign law is irrelevant. Justice Breyer's approach lacks any coherent theory explaining why foreign law is relevant and, for that reason alone, is less persuasive. I do think there are coherent theories of why foreign law might matter, but Justice Breyer has simply failed to identify or endorse any of them. Any thoughts, Chris or Peggy?


9 Comments:

Blogger liuyu7521 said...

MBT willchangeMBT bootsthe wayMTB ShoesWhat are the benefits?christian diorFree shippingdior shoeson all diordior handbagsDior isdior sunglassesanother good Dior totesbuy these goodsnew balancerevolutionary fitness new balance shoeswhich helpnew balance outlettransformsPuma Shoeswith top qualitypuma outletinnovative sole design Puma Sneakeryou can buy wholesale cl high heel sandalsquality and cheapMonclerVery Comfortable and lightmoncler jacketsoriginal packingmoncler coatsYou might say that thediscount moncler vestmoncler outletAs with everythingmoncler t-shirtThe new store north faceWe are offering you north face outletSome northfaceBut withinnorth face jacketsbecausediscount ugg bootsnorth face coats,cheap ugg bootsugg classic tall bootsugg boots,cheap ugg bootsclassic ugg bootsdiscount ugg bootswhich is uniqueclassic ugg bootsugg classic tall boots,ugg bootsGHD IV Salon StylerWe offercoach outletour coach handbagsNicecoach totesspyderspyder jacketsspyder ski wearspyder outlet

5/10/2010 11:57 PM  
Blogger mucheng said...

blu ray ripper
blu ray ripper
blu ray to avi
blu ray to wmv
blu ray to mp4
Furthermore, Blu ray Ripper has powerful editing functions like Trim and Crop Blu ray clips, add text/image Watermark as a logo, set video Effect like brightness, contrast, saturation, etc.

7/06/2010 3:27 AM  
Blogger Nike shox clearance said...

This is a great post,which has a lot of readers.
Such kind of post giving us various knowaledge,it worthy to read.It is so wonderful.

Our company provides Nike Shox Clearance rapid and safe, free shipping network marketing.

10/11/2010 10:17 PM  
Blogger aiya said...

Office 2010
Microsoft Office 2010
Microsoft word
Office 2007
Microsoft Office
Microsoft Office 2007
Office 2007 key
Office 2007 download
Office 2007 Professional
Outlook 2010
Microsoft outlook
Microsoft outlook 2010
Windows 7

11/04/2010 3:31 AM  
Blogger Lily said...

China wholesale shop
wholesale electronics
Tablet PC
discount fashion jewelry

wholesale clothing
wholesale toys
wholesale fashion bags
wholesale designer shoes
Wholesale SD Cards

Laptop Keyboard
Laptop Battery
Mens polo shirts
Vibram five fingers

4/09/2011 7:11 AM  
Blogger Nora said...

ghd uk is consistently the spirit using the marketplace of elite protection and comfort numerous rectifier. however Ghd Australia is frequently decent or adequate alternative is worth the price tag with Buy Ghd to obtain a stable temperatures to smooth. The frizzy hair along using the spirit for that enlarger of lush curls. A method of relaxation to collect your protection precisely ready for getting shipped on the same time handy universal.
Chi Camo Collection Flat Iron

7/15/2011 4:07 AM  
Blogger beautifuls said...

As we all know that Classic Cambridge Satchel is hot sale now in many online shops. today i will share you some shops to buy cheap cambridge satchel. There you can buy Music Cambridge Satchel and all kinds of cambridge satchel bag online in combridge satchel company. I think you will like i very much, so just enjoy your bags.
.

3/12/2012 2:41 AM  
Blogger GuildWars2Items said...

When you're down, and the world seems dark and empty, your forever friend lifts you up in spirits and makes that dark and empty world suddenly seem bright and full Diablo iii Gold Sale, this is Forever Friendship Diablo III Gold, someone who convinces you that there really is an unlocked door just waiting for you to open it Diablo 3 Gold.

3/27/2013 4:22 AM  
Blogger GuildWars2Items said...

Fear not that the life shall come to an end, but rather fear that it shall never have a beginning Sell RS Gold, What gets us into trouble is not what we don't know.It's what we know for sure that just ain't so Sell Runescape Gold, Life is like a hot bath. It feels good while you're in it, but the longer Sell RS Gold you stay in, the more wrinkled you get.

3/27/2013 5:01 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home