Tuesday, September 13, 2005

Judge Roberts Hearing: Use of Foreign Law in Constitutional Cases

I am back on the blog and wanted to post this exchange between Roberts and Senator Kyl (R. Ariz.) at today's hearing of Judge Roberts. (For background on the contours of the debate, see Jeff Toobin's New Yorker piece (via Scotusblog) on Justice Kennedy's "cosmopolitanism" and the use of foreign law).

KYL: It's an American Constitution, not a European or an African or an Asian one. And its meaning, it seems to me, by definition, cannot be determined by reference to foreign law. I also think it would put us on a dangerous path by trying to pick and choose among those foreign laws that we liked or didn't like. For example, many nations have a weak protection for freedom to participate in or practice one's religion. Iran and some other Middle Eastern nations come immediately to mind. But even a modern Western nation like France has placed restrictions on religious symbols in the public square. That would be highly unlikely to pass muster in U.S. courts. Should we look to France to tell us what the free exercise clause means, for example? Even nations that share our common law tradition such as Great Britain offer fewer civil liberty guarantees than we do. And the press has far less freedom. Nations such as Canada have allowed their judges to craft a constitutional right to homosexual marriage. There's a lot more to say on the subject. But I wanted to hear from you. So my question is this: What, if anything, is the proper role of foreign law in U.S. Supreme Court decisions? And, of course, we're not talking about interpreting treaties or foreign contracts of that sort, but cases such as those that would involve interpretations of the U.S. Constitution.

ROBERTS: Well, I don't want to comment on any particular case but I think I can speak more generally about the approach. I know Justices Scalia and Breyer had a little debate about it themselves here in town that was very illuminating to get both of their views.
And I would say, as a general matter, that there are a couple of things that cause concern on my part about the use of foreign law as precedent. As you say, this isn't about interpreting treaties or foreign contracts but as precedent on the meaning of American law. The first has to do with democratic theory. Judicial decisions: In this country, judges, of course, are not accountable to the people, but we are appointed through a process that allows for participation of the electorate. The president who nominates judges is obviously accountable to the people. Senators who confirm judges are accountable to people. And in that way, the role of the judge is consistent with the democratic theory.

ROBERTS: If we're relying on a decision from a German judge about what our Constitution means, no president accountable to the people appointed that judge and no Senate accountable to the people confirmed that judge. And yet he's playing a role in shaping the law that binds the people in this country. I think that's a concern that has to be addressed. The other part of it that would concern me is that, relying on foreign precedent doesn't confine judges. It doesn't limit their discretion the way relying on domestic precedent does. Domestic precedent can confine and shape the discretion of the judges. Foreign law, you can find anything you want. If you don't find it in the decisions of France or Italy, it's in the decisions of Somalia or Japan or Indonesia or wherever. As somebody said in another context, looking at foreign law for support is like looking out over a crowd and picking out your friends. You can find them. They're there. And that actually expands the discretion of the judge. It allows the judge to incorporate his or her own personal preferences, cloak them with the authority of precedent -- because they're finding precedent in foreign law -- and use that to determine the meaning of the Constitution. And I think that's a misuse of precedent, not a correct use of precedent.

12 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

what about the notion that foreign law includes standards taken from, or that have contributed to, international law? Considering the participatory processes that form international law, foreign law may not be entirely alien to the U.S. citizenry. The term 'foreign law' refers to more than just foreign judicial decisions.

9/14/2005 2:43 PM  
Blogger Peggy McGuinness said...

Interesting question. This would arguably the case with precendent from the European Court of Human Rights which has both a "foreign" and "international" element. If the ECHR interprets a provision of the European Charter on Human Rights that is identical in language to a provision of the ICCPR (which several provisions are), it seems to me that precedent can appropriately be used in any other forum in which the text of the ICCPR provision is at issue. That might, for example, include the US, which has acceded to the ICCPR, albeit with significant reservations.

A distinction needs to be made between foreign judicial decisions and foreign statutes. Foreign statutes tell us very little about how to interpret our own constitutional questions, but can be used to describe trends (e.g., which countries recognize same-sex marriage). I would think that is the case whether or not the statute has been informed by international law.

9/15/2005 10:03 AM  
Blogger poston said...

There are ed hardy shirts
,pretty ed hardy shirt for men,

ed hardy womens in the ed hardy online store

designed by ed hardy ,
many cheap ed hardy shirt ,glasses,caps,trouers ed hardy shirts on sale ,

You can go to edhardyshirts.com to have a look ,you may find one of ed hardy clothing fit for you
Top qualitymen's jacket,
These cheap jacket are on sale now,you can find
north face jackets inmage on our web
Ralph Lauren Polo Shirtsbuberry polo shirts

Authentic chaussure puma
chaussure sport
And chaussure nike shoes
Come here to have a look of our Wholesale Jeans
Many fashionMens Jeans ,eye-catching
Womens Jeans ,and special out standing
Blue Jeans ,you can spend less money on our
Discount Jeans but gain really fine jeans, absolutely a great bargain.
http://www.weddingdressseason.com

http://CLOTHES-WHOLESALE.US

7/08/2009 5:12 AM  
Blogger Apa Saja Dah said...

Find and download what you need at Rapidshare Search Engine.
Top Site List Free Proxy Site Free Download mp3 Michael Jackson song All Michael Jackson Lirics Oes Tsetnoc Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa

11/09/2009 11:14 AM  
Blogger unazero said...

Thank you for this article. That's all I can say. You most definitely have made this blog into something special. You clearly know what you are doing, you've covered so many bases.Thanks!

RS Gold

MapleStory Mesos

10/24/2011 3:35 AM  
Blogger beautifuls said...

Buy Cheap Fluro Cambridge Satchel Cambridge Satchel Fluro Fluro Yellow Cambridge Satchel Fluro Pink Cambridge Satchel Cambridge Satchel Fluro Yellow Cambridge Satchel Fluro Pink with lower price and high quality.

2/23/2012 9:42 PM  
Blogger Rainman Mark said...

I liked your article, I will share your article to everyone!!




RS gold|Diablo 3 Gold|GW2 gold|WoW Gold

3/02/2013 6:09 AM  
Blogger Learn Chinese language on hanbridgemandarin said...

I'm learning to speak Chinese because I believe it's the only way to really learn about China.When I was searching for a place to learn to speak Chinese, I called several schools. Hanbridge was the best because they had excellent teachers and a very friendly and welcoming spirit. ?I really appreciate the opportunity to learn here and would recommend Hanbridge to others.

2/02/2015 2:57 AM  
Blogger ninest123 Ninest said...

ninest123 08.05
ray ban sunglasses, prada outlet, michael kors outlet, tory burch outlet, replica watches, louboutin, burberry, michael kors outlet, tiffany and co, polo ralph lauren outlet, coach factory outlet, burberry outlet online, gucci outlet, longchamp, nike air max, longchamp outlet, nike air max, michael kors, christian louboutin outlet, chanel handbags, oakley sunglasses, michael kors outlet, prada handbags, kate spade handbags, kate spade outlet, nike free, longchamp outlet, louboutin outlet, coach outlet, ray ban sunglasses, coach outlet, michael kors outlet, oakley sunglasses, michael kors outlet, true religion jeans, oakley sunglasses, jordan shoes, tiffany jewelry, coach purses, nike outlet, polo ralph lauren outlet, louboutin shoes

8/05/2015 4:10 AM  
Blogger ninest123 Ninest said...

timberland, oakley pas cher, nike air max, north face, north face, new balance pas cher, nike roshe run, nike air max, air max, ralph lauren pas cher, sac longchamp, abercrombie and fitch, nike air max, michael kors, lululemon, air force, true religion jeans, vanessa bruno, louboutin pas cher, true religion outlet, nike free, longchamp pas cher, hogan, nike free run uk, ray ban pas cher, burberry, michael kors, ray ban uk, vans pas cher, hollister, nike blazer, michael kors, converse pas cher, tn pas cher, ralph lauren uk, sac guess, lacoste pas cher, true religion jeans, hollister pas cher, mulberry, air jordan pas cher, hermes

8/05/2015 4:10 AM  
Blogger ninest123 Ninest said...

asics running shoes, longchamp, mcm handbags, hollister, oakley, nike air max, beats by dre, north face outlet, jimmy choo shoes, mac cosmetics, new balance, soccer jerseys, vans shoes, valentino shoes, reebok shoes, chi flat iron, lululemon, p90x workout, abercrombie and fitch, giuseppe zanotti, ferragamo shoes, nike roshe, celine handbags, timberland boots, nike roshe, instyler, nike huarache, north face outlet, wedding dresses, insanity workout, nfl jerseys, herve leger, nike trainers, bottega veneta, baseball bats, hollister, mont blanc, soccer shoes, iphone 6 cases, birkin bag, ghd, babyliss

8/05/2015 4:11 AM  
Blogger ninest123 Ninest said...

lancel, coach outlet, wedding dresses, juicy couture outlet, swarovski, ugg boots, pandora charms, converse outlet, hollister, ugg boots uk, ray ban, ugg boots, ugg,ugg australia,ugg italia, replica watches, uggs on sale, nike air max, thomas sabo, pandora jewelry, ugg pas cher, hollister, louboutin, marc jacobs, pandora charms, bottes ugg, links of london, gucci, montre pas cher, swarovski crystal, karen millen, ugg,uggs,uggs canada, ugg boots, vans, juicy couture outlet, toms shoes, ugg boots, ralph lauren, supra shoes, converse
ninest123 08.05

8/05/2015 4:11 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home