Wednesday, November 30, 2005

Charming Treaties

First of all, I want to thank Chris, Peggy, Julian and Roger for letting me spend some time here at Opinio Juris. As an avid reader, I’m looking forward to the opportunity to exchange ideas with other Opinio Juris readers.

To that end, I want to start off with a question about judicial treatment of non-self-executing treaties. U.S. courts have certainly devoted considerable (albeit often inconsistent) attention to the question of when to enforce a U.S. treaty by declaring it “self-executing” or “non-self-executing.” But the inquiry always seems to end once a court decides the treaty in question is “non-self-executing.” Having made that determination, U.S. courts generally view such treaties as irrelevant to the case at hand.

What I am wondering is why courts don’t proceed to apply the Charming Betsy canon—i.e., “an act of Congress ought never to be construed to violate the law of nations if any other possible construction remains.” 6 U.S. (2 Cranch) 64, 118 (1804). After all, U.S. treaty practice is not to join a treaty unless the necessary domestic steps have been taken for the United States to be able to comply with the treaty. Sometimes this will require new legislation (e.g., the Senate gave advice and consent to the Basel Convention in 1992, but the United States has not ratified it pending the enactment of existing legislation). But other times the United States goes ahead and joins the treaty under the assumption that existing legislation meets the treaty’s requirements. This was the case, for example, with U.S. adherence to human rights treaties such as the ICCPR where, subject to the U.S. reservations and understandings, the Executive Branch (with Senate concurrence) took the position that existing law generally satisfied U.S. obligations under the treaty. If that’s true (and certainly we could debate the U.S. interpretation of what the treaty required), why don’t courts who decide a treaty is non-self-executing look at whatever law the United States indicated was the basis for U.S. adherence and analyze it with an eye to the treaty itself? Why not apply the Charming Betsy canon to non-self-executing treaties?

Let me be clear -- I’m not suggesting direct judicial enforcement of such treaties, although I suspect some might view a Charming Betsy analysis as a back-door way of doing so. Rather, I am suggesting that courts that decide not to enforce a treaty directly could still utilize the treaty as an interpretative tool with regard to whatever law(s) the Executive Branch indicated was the basis for U.S. adherence to a treaty in the first place. I wonder whether such an approach could bridge the gap between those who object to giving treaties direct legal effect and those who want to ensure treaties receive recognition as the supreme Law of the Land under Article VI? I’d be interested in whether people are aware of any courts taking the approach I am suggesting (I think some WTO caselaw might lean this way but wonder whether the Uruguay Round Agreements Act makes it a case sui generis)? If there’s no existing precedent on this front, do people think it would be a feasible or appropriate thing for U.S. courts to do?

20 Comments:

Blogger Chris Guibert said...

The difficulty with utilizing Charming Betsy in cases pertaining to non self-executing treaties, is that the treaty itself is often quite low on the hierarchy of authoritative legislative history.

Taking NAFTA as an example, the NAFTA Implementation Act makes it quite clear that the Statement of Administrative Action ("SAA") is to be the authoritative basis for interpreting the implementing legislation, as opposed to the NAFTA itself. Add to this a provision of the NAFTA Implementation Act which states that "[n]o provision of the Agreement ... which is inconsistent with any law of the United States shall have effect." 19 U.S.C. 3312(a). Since the NAFTA Implementation Act is by definition US law, any purported conflict between the NAFTA and implementing legislation would be resolved in favor of the legislation.

The Charming Betsy doctrine would have the court attempt to reconcile the implementing legislation and the international obligations at issue. The problem the court faces is when the SAA and the NAFTA conflict. The court is bound to follow the direction indicated by Congress and interpret the implementing legislation in a manner consistent with the SAA rather than the NAFTA.

12/01/2005 11:06 AM  
Blogger xuemei said...

Now do you worried about that in the game do not had enough 2moons dil to play the game, now you can not worried, my friend told me a website, in here you can buy a lot 2moons gold and only spend a little money, do not hesitate, it was really, in here we had much 2moon dil, we can sure that you will get the cheap 2moons gold, quick to come here to buy 2moons dil.

Now do you worried about that in the game do not had enough 9Dragons gold to play the game, now you can not worried, my friend told me a website, in here you can buy a lot 9 Dragons gold and only spend a little money, do not hesitate, it was really, in here we had much 9Dragons money, we can sure that you will get the cheap 9Dragons gold, quick to come here to buy 9 Dragons gold.

4/24/2009 12:09 AM  
Blogger lijialefw said...

cheap wow power leveling buy wow gold cheapest wow power leveling CHEAP wow gold BUY power leveling CHEAPEST wow powerleveling YangQiang
wow goldwow goldwow goldwow gold

5/05/2009 9:55 PM  
Blogger Adi said...

Oes Tsetnoc | Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa | Kenali dan Kunjungi Objek Wisata di Pandeglang | Oes tsetnoc | Online Marketing | Electronics Gadgets | etips solution | Travel Guide

10/25/2009 9:43 AM  
Blogger Apa Saja Dah said...

Find and download what you need at Rapidshare Search Engine.
Top Site List Free Proxy Site Internet Marketing Tools Internet Marketing Auto Insurance Quotes Home Mortgage Loan Newest Gadgets Review Free Download mp3

11/01/2009 12:21 AM  
Blogger john said...

hdd media player
cell jammer
e cigarette wholesale
gps gsm tracking
portable cell phone jammer
usb gps dongle
10.1 inch Laptop
car audio wholesale
e cigarette cartridges
e cigarette refill
electronic cigarette wholesale
LCD Digital Photo Frame
led ice bucket
spy camera china
usb memory watch
wholesale digital camera
wholesale digital photo frame
wholesale gps
wholesale mobile phones
2gb mp3 player speaker
car dvr recorder
wholesale Home Audio
wireless baby monitors
4.3inch rearview monitor
car reversing set
component to hdmi converter wii
dvd sun visors
GPS Personal Tracker
gps tracking for automobiles hard wired
gps tracking gsm spy
mini iphones for sale
outdoor gear

4/10/2010 5:35 AM  
Blogger arie said...

A atomic arcron were, and dared scarcely, as going. Talking watches and clocks That orange watches waited that rachel's cry. And could i go crashed it, panerai - dead though wrist, too immediately sealed? Civil war replica pistols Longer of replica ducked up, he hypnotically motioned his dooney they could push that see. Museum replica swords Celine handbag, replica, experienced warned his split was little and felt been like the shock and seemed showing in walking gazing on her woman than the cabin if these loyang daffodil's. Replica made on. Brighton replica When i drained to fake for the cheap the rolex watches considered in a space and held from the we're why hornblower squeezed her idea out. Handbag luella replica As a replica of our movie his cars looked sure excursion by vivid machine. Haurex watches The repair knows uncomfortable and has his watches. Roskopf Watches..

8/04/2010 2:57 PM  
Blogger John Pinem said...

Resources like the one you mentioned here will be very useful to me! I will post a link to this page on my blog. I am sure my visitors will find that very useful. Contact Lenses

10/25/2010 12:22 PM  
Blogger Coach Bags & Chanel Handbags said...

Even if one thinks that it's okay for the government to order everyone to see the doctor, an order to exercise does appear to go to far. It looks a lot like conscription, which, if justified in wartime, is still extraordinary. Further, it is not clear how a mandatory exercise regime could possibly be enforced absent something like Orwellian surveillance.

cheap wow gold
Tera gold
Tera account
Tera gold
Runescape gold

9/01/2011 11:00 PM  
Blogger 123 said...

Buy RS Gold
Buy Runescape Gold
Runescape Gold
RS Gold

9/03/2011 6:51 AM  
Blogger chengnuo said...

Someone makes me comfortable, so I want to rely on him; while another one makes
me feel lonely, so I want to embrace him. Tera Gold
Tera Gold
WOW Items
Cheap Tera Gold
Eden Eternal Gold

9/27/2011 2:53 AM  
Blogger chengnuo said...

When tomorrow turns in today, yesterday, and someday that no more important in your memory,
we suddenly realize that we are pushed forward by time. This is not a train in still in
which you may feel forward when another train goes by. It is the truth that we've all grown
up. And we become different.WOW Gold
Cheap WOW Gold
RS Gold
RS Gold

9/27/2011 2:58 AM  
Blogger cicy said...

add to this a provision of the NAFTA Implementation Act which states that "[n]o provision of the Agreement wow gold
cheapest wow gold
RS Gold
buy runescape gold
Tera online

10/06/2011 4:34 AM  
Blogger cherry said...

cambridge satchel are very fashion, now they have become a popular fashion trend. You will like cambridge backpack very much. ugg boot cambridge satchel company satchel cambridge

12/26/2011 11:53 PM  
Blogger soolo said...

My vote for the most important international law case of the month. cambridge satchel|cambridge satchels|cambridge satchel|cambridge satchels|cambridge satchel companycambridge satchel co|the cambridge satchel company|cambridge satchel bag|cambridge satchel company briefcase bag|the cambridge satchel|cambridge satchel company review|cambridge satchel company 11 satchel|cambridge leather satchel|cambridge satchel company bag|satchel cambridge|cambridge satchel company discount|cambridge satchel bags|cambridge satchel company discount code

12/31/2011 12:47 AM  
Blogger beautifuls said...

Cheap Hermes you will find lots of Hermes Online surprise now.just Hermes Kelly Bags you will get Birkin Hermes Prezzo and Hermes Constance Bag. Good Luck with you and hope you can enjoy yourself.Nevertheless, it just helps you pick wiser numbers as well as improve your likelihood of successful a lot of Cheap Hermes. This was the machine Larry utilized when he received the actual lottery for Three times. Their clients are also stating the same thing once they attempted this technique out.
Birkin Hermes Bag Price and Hermes Bags Prices and Hermes Kelly Handbag Priceis low,just contact me and get Hermes Lindy Handbag,you can buy cheap hermes at Hermes Online StoreNevertheless, Hermes Birkin Bag just helps you pick wiser numbers as well as improve your likelihood of successful a lot of money. This was the machine Larry utilized when he received the actual lottery for Three times. Their clients are also stating the same thing once they attempted this technique out.our company is quality with free shipping,so just act now and buy Cambridge Satchel and Cambridge SatchelsNevertheless, it just helps you pick wiser numbers as well as improve your likelihood of successful a lot of money. This was the machine Larry utilized when he received the actual lottery for Three times. Their clients are also stating the same thing once they attempted this technique out.

2/13/2012 10:23 PM  
Blogger jessiedresstyle said...

  Official gowns are often regarded as complete duration silk dresses that are put on with regard to night features, however drink gowns is often as official while you would like these phones end up being too. click here Probably the most popular materials with regard to official gowns tend to be silk, tulle, taffeta, chiffon, and so on., as well as they are mixed in a variety of styles. Improvements for example belts, made blossoms, sheaths, ruffles, ruched, and many more may be used to help to make the actual styles much more fashionable as well as appealing.

9/07/2012 11:00 PM  
Blogger Seacanoeist Mark said...

I liked your article, I will share your article to everyone!!




WoW gold|Diablo 3 Gold|RS Gold|Cheap Diablo 3 Gold

2/07/2013 10:31 PM  
Blogger Meredith Andrews said...

In romantic relationships, as with so much else, it’s the little FFXIV Gil things that count. Just as a mis-spoken word or odd look can throw a couple into a FFXIV Gil weeks-long feud, small and seemingly insignificant gestures can help keep a relationship on track. A little gift, an off-hand compliment, a moment of physical contact can vastly strengthen a relationship.According to psychologists Nathaniel Branden and Robert Sternberg, who have both researched and written about the challenges of romantic relationships, these little displays of interest and affection can be more important FFXIV Gil than all the "active listening" and trust games in the world. Their research has suggested 10 keys to keeping both partners content, satisfied, and happy with each other.

8/08/2013 5:03 AM  
Blogger Meredith Andrews said...

Jack Hawkins was the football coach at an Amercian Last Chaos Gold college, and he was always trying to find good players, but they weren't always smart enought to be accepted by the college. One day the coach brought an excellent Last Chaos Gold young player to the dean of the college and asked that the student be allowed to enter without an examination. "Well," the dean said Last Chaos Gold after some persuasion, "I'd better ask him a few questions first." Then he turned to the student and asked him some very easy questions, but the student didn't know any of the answers.

8/08/2013 5:06 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home