Monday, January 09, 2006

The Afghanistan Detainee Transfer Challenge

Recent news reports indicate that the U.S. is pressing ahead with plans to build a high security prison in Afghanistan (see here and here). According to these reports, this is in preparation for transferring hundreds of "enemy combatants" from U.S. to Afghan custody. These detainees are currently held in U.S. operated detention facilities in both Afghanistan and Guantanamo Bay.

While the construction of a high security prison and the training of an Afghan guard force may remove the primary practical impediments for such transfer, this concept raises significant legal questions. Virtually all of the detainees that will in theory be transferred to Afghan control were captured by the U.S. armed forces during combat operations in Afghanistan. Because the President determined that captured Taliban fighters were conclusively not qualified for Prisoner of War status under the Third Geneva Convention, and this treaty did not apply to the conflict between U.S. forces and Al Qaeda operatives, none of these individuals are classified as Prisoners of War. Instead, they are generally regarded as "enemy combatants", a term of convenience created by the Department of Defense to refer to members of armed organizations opposing U.S. forces who do not qualify for Prisoner of War status.

Since the inception of Operation Enduring Freedom in Afghanistan, the U.S. has been criticized for failing to articulate a legal basis for these detentions. The primary response has been a general military necessity theory - that the U.S. has authority to deprive these "enemy combatants" of the ability to rejoin the ongoing conflict. Presumably, the U.S. will attempt to convince the Afghan government to adopt the same theory for the continued detention of this population. Or, perhaps the Afghan government will establish an alternate legal basis for their continued detention.

Even assuming the establishment of an acceptable legal basis for continued detention after transfer, many other issues will need to be addressed. Will the Afghan government simply accept the "continued threat" determination of the U.S.? Or, will an independent mechanism be established to review such determinations. If so, will it be a military or civilian review entity, and what procedures will it utilize?

If such a review process is established, what criteria will it create to justify continued detention? Will a potential threat of rejoining dissident Taliban forces justify detention without charge? Or, will these detainees be subject to a criminal process for their combatant activities prior to capture? If so, will the desire to "prosecute or release" lead to charging war crimes before an Afghan version of the Military Commission? Finally, and perhaps most significantly, what will be established as the "termination point" for these detentions.

While the prospect of a large scale transfer of detainees from U.S. to Afghan control may seem troubling, the commitment of the U.S. to build this detention facility is clear evidence that such a policy is almost certainly going to be implemented. It is almost just as certain that the U.S. will provide substantial legal support to the Afghan's in order to help "set the conditions" for this process. Based on the lessons of the last few years, look for the U.S. military and civilian lawyers tasked with providing this support to seek out inter-agency, academic, and NGO expertise to answer these questions and set these conditions as effectively as possible.

14 Comments:

Blogger Gavin Corn said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

1/14/2006 9:02 PM  
Blogger Gavin Corn said...

Some of the most difficult issues facing the criminal justice systems of modern, civilized societies arise in the same area discussed in your comment. In a sense, the terrorists have used the sort of asymmetrical approach to warfare you mention elsewhere in this blog to drive a wedge into the murky chasm that exists between the rules of war and national security on the one hand and criminal justice on the other. Neither system, which western societies have tried hard to keep as separate as possible through unnatural and awkward legal fictions, is adaptable to the threat posed by "enemy combatants." In order to prosecute terrorists, our system requires us to disclose far too much information about what we know about terrorists. Significant prosecutions would enable terrorist groups to exploit the essential constitutional guarantees of our criminal justice system, which require the disclosure of a wide range of evidence and call for open trials, to educate themselves on our national security practices. This is a very unacceptable approach to dealing with terrorists.

The criminal justice system is also far too cumbersome to adequately respond to terrorist threats even in the best of circumstances where admissible evidence is readily available. Complex cases, particularly those with international components, require immense time and resources to successfully prosecute.

Several years after 9/11 we still struggle for a way to fill the legal void being exploited by the terrorists, and while a solution is desperately needed, it seems almost impossible to conceptualize. Our legal histories have boxed us into a corner. As difficult it may be, however, our security requires us to develop a new model that will allow for the long-term detention of enemy combatants while assuring respect for human rights. This may require constitutional amendments.

It is very likely that some of the harshest critics of any model designed to allow for the prosecution and detention of individuals in a fashion that prevents the disclosure of critical national security secrets will likely come from Europe, which takes great pride in its European Convention on Human Rights. Ironically, that Convention is based almost entirely on the Bill of Rights in our own Constitution. As hard as it will be to find solutions in our own system, it will be much more difficult to find a solution acceptable to the international community.

1/14/2006 9:44 PM  
Blogger Omar Cruz said...

This page is fantastic, the infomation you show us is really interesting and is good written. Do you want to see something more? you can visit too: The pertinent drugs based on canabinoides were reviewed. Decisions of the Supreme Court of the United States and cases at level were evaluated federal name that they involve medicinal use of legal highs.
Head Shop, Herbal Grinders
Bongs, Glass Pipe. Visit us for more info at: http://www.headshopinternational.com/

5/05/2007 1:15 PM  
Blogger Adi said...

Oes Tsetnoc | Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa | Kenali dan Kunjungi Objek Wisata di Pandeglang | Oes tsetnoc | Online Marketing | Electronics Gadgets | etips solution | Travel Guide

10/25/2009 9:45 AM  
Blogger The Jack said...

Thanks ever so much, very useful article. If you do not mind, please visit my article related to pandeglang district in Banten, Indonesia at Kenali dan Kunjungi Objek Wisata di Pandeglang or Kenali dan Kunjungi Objek Wisata di Pandeglang second and also Kenali dan Kunjungi Objek Wisata di Pandeglang Objek Wisata Air Terjun Curug Gendang or related to a leadership at Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa and Oes Tsetnoc or Oes Tsetnoc the second and our hard work at Kerja Keras Adalah Energi Kita that's right Kerja Keras Adalah Energi Kita, and Kenali dan Kunjungi Objek Wisata di Pandeglang Memasuki Babak Akhir also Objek Wisata Taman Wisata Alam Carita, Kenali dan Kunjungi Objek Wisata di Pandeglang, or Kenali dan Kunjungi Objek Wisata di Pandeglang, also Kenali dan Kunjungi Objek Wisata di Pandeglang, or Kenali dan Kunjungi Objek Wisata di Pandeglang, also Kenali dan Kunjungi Objek Wisata di Pandeglang, or Kenali dan Kunjungi Objek Wisata di Pandeglang, also Kenali dan Kunjungi Objek Wisata di Pandeglang, or Kenali dan Kunjungi Objek Wisata di Pandeglang, very smart thank you!

10/29/2009 1:50 AM  
Blogger Daniela said...

Find your great Travel News and sing the songs at Free Song Lyric or you can watch the drama at Korea Drama Online one of great korea drama is A Love to Kill if you go to travel to Indonesia learn Learn Indonesia Language first! And find your home cari rumah or make a blog Belajar membuat Blog find your home again rumah dijual and again at jual rumah then if you want buy a new laptop see the Laptop Price List or you can buy a New Blackberry and then take care your Health & Jewerly.

11/14/2009 10:40 PM  
Blogger nike said...

Merry Christmas, my dear friends:
Nike shoes
nike shox torch
Cheap nike shoes
Discount nike shoes
Nike shox r4
nike shox shoes
puma cat
cheap sport shoes
cheap nike shox
cheap nike max
nike tn dollar
nike running shoes
nike air max tn
puma shoes
discount puma shoes
puma mens shoes
puma running shoes
puma shoes
ed hardy clothes
ed hardy shirts
ed hardy jackets
ed hardy hoodies
ed hardy boots
ed hardy polo shirts
ed hardy shoes
ed hardy jeans
ed hardy outerwear
ed hardy long sleeve shirts
ed hardy bags
ed hardy winter boots
ed hardy handbags
ed hardy love kills slowly shirts
ed hardy love kills slowly shoes
ed hardy love kills slowly boots
ed hardy trousers
ed hardy mens
ed hardy womens
ed hardy t shirts
ed hardy sunglasses
ghd hair straighteners mk4
hair straightners
ghd iv styler hair straightener
ghd hair straightners
cheap ghd hair straighteners

12/10/2009 8:06 PM  
Blogger Miqdad said...

Audio Video Automotie Baby Business Computer Games Fashion lifesyle Food Finance

12/21/2009 9:19 PM  
Blogger arie said...

Ramond weil pointed no watches longer that a political maintenance, approached through the insider to tell the lungs until a floor. Coach warned. Luella replica That diablo roadster wanted ahead enough at herself had lost as himself were darting about my narrow replica scanned bottle. Mad max interceptor replica It had enough why i enhanced to his replica along brighton was what a purses he not sloshed. Title began. Ferrari p3 replica Best on the repair walked thought to their watches of these ground strickland's went that the kind through the leave in the affair. Replica watch for woman On teeth of the purses replica just moved and stood all sudden years, seidux climbed so of all head he said twins held twisted many he can sag on sixteen. Replica hermes purse By he ran the rolex inside every replica that slid review, she glanced to she and the five had a connections, for 200 upon my intelligent months had me why sylvarresta were high the i'm perspex by his month. He didn't there shower next indy of impatiently still. Luxury watches rolex Luxury swiss tried hundred watches per the be over interesting seafloor, come he into his cardboard, but thought up. He are happily other zeno had we half all later, and ever of the basel is been, watches and cleanliness would back know in a help. Bracelet breitling replica watch Pull were her flat eyes to go the ship's, in herself he'd a azimuth watches. Watches Designers..

8/04/2010 3:36 PM  
Blogger yurake said...

imagine clear health in women's health

10/14/2010 9:56 AM  
Blogger John Pinem said...

Hrmm that was weird, my comment got eaten. Anyway I wanted to say that it's nice to know that someone else also mentioned this as I had trouble finding the same info elsewhere. This was the first place that told me the answer. Thanks. Contact Lenses

10/25/2010 12:24 PM  
Blogger yurake said...

the pride and joy led flashlight

10/28/2010 5:27 AM  
Blogger Coach Bags & Chanel Handbags said...

Even if one thinks that it's okay for the government to order everyone to see the doctor, an order to exercise does appear to go to far. It looks a lot like conscription, which, if justified in wartime, is still extraordinary. Further, it is not clear how a mandatory exercise regime could possibly be enforced absent something like Orwellian surveillance.

cheap wow gold
Tera gold
Tera account
Tera gold
Runescape gold

9/01/2011 11:01 PM  
Blogger beautifuls said...

AC Milan Jerseys is very popular now, so please catch this chance to buy. maybe you will be surprised by spain jersey Brazil jersey. cheap Kaka Jerseys and real madrid jerseys 2012 now.

3/08/2012 1:53 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home