Thursday, February 02, 2006

Case of the Month: United States v. Clark

My vote for the most important international law case in January is the Ninth Circuit's decision in United States v. Clark. The case represents a rare and important instance of a court attempting to grapple with the scope of the Foreign Commerce Clause.

Michael Clark was convicted of traveling to Cambodia to engage in commercial sex with a minor in violation of federal law. The relevant statute, 18 U.S.C. § 2423(c), provides that "... Any United States citizen or alien admitted for permanent residence who travels in foreign commerce, and engages in any illicit sexual conduct with another person shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than 30 years, or both."

Clark first argued that the statute violated international law principles of prescriptive jurisdiction. The Ninth Circuit recognized the presumption against extraterritoriality, but concluded that this statute is explicit as to its application outside the United States. Moreover, the statute complied with international law principles in that it applied to U.S. nationals, which clearly is recognized under the nationality principle. Although not addressed in the case, an open question is whether the same would be true if Clark were a permanent resident rather than a U.S. citizen.

More significant, Clark argued that Congress exceeded its power under the Foreign Commerce Clause in enacting § 2423(c). The statute is problematic under the Foreign Commerce Clause in that it regulates "illicit sexual conduct," which embraces both non-commercial and commercial sex with minors. The Court offered an extensive analysis of the Interstate Commerce Clause, the Indian Commerce Clause, and the Foreign Commerce Clause to determine the scope of congressional authority to regulate foreign commercial sexual acts.

The Ninth Circuit distinguished Interstate Commerce jurisprudence and focused on the sweeping powers granted to Congress to regulate foreign commerce and the absence of traditional federalism concerns under this Clause. "Born largely from a desire for uniform rules governing commercial relations with foreign countries, the Supreme Court has read the Foreign Commerce Clause as granting Congress sweeping powers.... The Court has been unwavering in reading Congress's power over foreign commerce broadly.... There is no counterpart to Lopez or Morrison in the foreign commerce realm that would signal a retreat from the Court's expansive reading of the Foreign Commerce Clause." Applied to Clark's conduct, the Ninth Circuit concluded that "[t]raveling to a foreign country and paying a child to engage in sex acts are indispensable ingredients of the crime to which Clark pled guilty.... Congress did not exceed its power 'to regulate Commerce with foreign Nations' ... in criminalizing commercial sex acts with minors committed by U.S. citizens abroad."

In dissent, Judge Ferguson argued that the conduct of Clark did not constitute commerce with foreign nations and therefore was beyond the scope of congressional regulation. "[A]n act of paid sex with a minor that takes place overseas is not an act of commerce with other nations. Under the interpretation of the majority, the purchase of a lunch in France by an American citizen who traveled there by airplane would constitute a constitutional act of engaging in foreign commerce."

It is remarkable how little attention is paid to the Foreign Commerce Clause in constitutional Commerce Clause analysis. Clark offers a useful perspective on the scope of congressional authority to regulate commercial and non-commercial sexual conduct that occurs abroad. The case was relatively easy because Clark was a U.S. citizen who paid for sex with a minor in a foreign country. But the statute was not limited to commercial sex, regulating any illicit sex with a minor in a foreign country that would be a violation of U.S. law had it occurred within the United States. The broadest application of that statute could raise interesting issues about the authority of Congress to regulate non-commercial foreign acts pursuant to the Foreign Commerce Clause.

It is simply astonishing that in 2006 the Ninth Circuit can begin a case by stating "we are confronted with a question of first impression regarding the scope of Congress's power under the Foreign Commerce Clause." Clark is well worth a close read by any scholar interested in that question.

12 Comments:

Blogger Antonio said...

Interesting read - But I honestly think the 9th Circuit was completely correct in their finding. While there is wide dispute as to the exact intention and nature of the Commerce Clause, it is very likely that it was intended to empower Congress to regulate much more than simply money. The meaning of the word "commerce" in the late 18th century had a much broader and different meaning than it does today.

Further, the Congress is the sole federal legislative body and if it makes any law regulating the behavior of it's citizenry, which it has the power to due under police power and public saftey doctines, then so be it as long as those same laws do not violate other areas of the Constitution. Further, these laws can be extended to acts comitted by US nationals acting abroad via the nationality doctrine of widely accepted international law.

With all due repsect to Judge Ferguson, I must disagree with his reasoning that Congress is overstepping here. I do agree that Clark's behavior of engaging in sex with a minor does not constitute a commerce transaction, in the MODERN SENSE, between the USA and a foreign entity. However, when extrapolating the word commerce into the true intetntion of the Framers, well that is another story.

For what it's worth...

1/24/2008 5:07 PM  
Blogger Adi said...

Oes Tsetnoc one of the ways in which we can learn seo besides Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa. By participating in the Oes Tsetnoc or Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa we can improve our seo skills. To find more information about Oest Tsetnoc please visit my Oes Tsetnoc pages. And to find more information about Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa please visit my Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa pages. Thank you So much.
Oes Tsetnoc | Semangat Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa

11/22/2009 10:15 AM  
Blogger Barbara said...

Nice blog .. I never thought that you going to write about it:) thanks a lot

viagra online

buy viagra

generic viagra

6/07/2010 4:58 PM  
Blogger zhengbin said...

Other ways to unlock trapped cash thomas sabo is in the form of selling thomas sabo shop silverware, silver flatware, sterling silver thomas sabo jewellery and scrap silver.

10/28/2010 8:40 PM  
Blogger guccipurse4u said...

cambridge satchel red cambridge satchel bag cambridge satchel backpack yellow cambridge satchel cambridge satchel pinkcambridge satchel greencambridge satchel purple cambridge satchel black cambridge satchel embossed

3/04/2012 9:46 PM  
Blogger ninest123 Ninest said...

ninest123 08.11
louboutin, nike free, burberry outlet online, michael kors outlet, burberry, nike outlet, louboutin shoes, ray ban sunglasses, chanel handbags, longchamp outlet, michael kors outlet, nike air max, ray ban sunglasses, tory burch outlet, coach outlet, replica watches, coach purses, polo ralph lauren outlet, michael kors outlet, tiffany jewelry, christian louboutin outlet, coach outlet, michael kors outlet, gucci outlet, prada outlet, longchamp outlet, tiffany and co, longchamp, oakley sunglasses, michael kors outlet, jordan shoes, kate spade handbags, polo ralph lauren outlet, true religion jeans, oakley sunglasses, nike air max, coach factory outlet, louboutin outlet, prada handbags, kate spade outlet, oakley sunglasses, michael kors

8/11/2015 2:30 AM  
Blogger ninest123 Ninest said...

new balance pas cher, nike air max, nike roshe run, hollister, michael kors, true religion jeans, north face, true religion jeans, lululemon, sac guess, timberland, longchamp pas cher, ray ban pas cher, sac longchamp, abercrombie and fitch, nike air max, air force, mulberry, burberry, nike free run uk, ray ban uk, lacoste pas cher, north face, ralph lauren uk, michael kors, nike blazer, true religion outlet, oakley pas cher, nike free, hogan, vans pas cher, hermes, air max, nike air max, air jordan pas cher, michael kors, ralph lauren pas cher, hollister pas cher, converse pas cher, tn pas cher, vanessa bruno, louboutin pas cher

8/11/2015 2:33 AM  
Blogger ninest123 Ninest said...

birkin bag, lululemon, timberland boots, nfl jerseys, baseball bats, celine handbags, babyliss, chi flat iron, mac cosmetics, nike air max, longchamp, ferragamo shoes, mont blanc, herve leger, insanity workout, vans shoes, ghd, iphone 6 cases, hollister, valentino shoes, hollister, reebok shoes, jimmy choo shoes, nike roshe, nike roshe, soccer jerseys, wedding dresses, mcm handbags, nike huarache, new balance, instyler, giuseppe zanotti, p90x workout, north face outlet, bottega veneta, abercrombie and fitch, north face outlet, oakley, soccer shoes, nike trainers, asics running shoes, beats by dre

8/11/2015 2:35 AM  
Blogger ninest123 Ninest said...

hollister, ugg boots uk, thomas sabo, ugg boots, lancel, uggs on sale, karen millen, links of london, ray ban, louboutin, ralph lauren, bottes ugg, converse outlet, ugg boots, replica watches, ugg boots, converse, gucci, toms shoes, hollister, coach outlet, nike air max, juicy couture outlet, ugg boots, ugg,uggs,uggs canada, supra shoes, ugg,ugg australia,ugg italia, vans, swarovski crystal, wedding dresses, swarovski, ugg pas cher, pandora charms, montre pas cher, marc jacobs, juicy couture outlet, pandora charms, pandora jewelry
ninest123 08.11

8/11/2015 2:37 AM  
Blogger 柯云 said...

2015-12-23keyun
oakley sunglasses wholesale
ugg boots sale
uggs on sale
ugg outlet
michael kors outlet
retro 11
michael kors handbags
discount ugg boots
cheap oakleys
uggs for sale
giuseppe zanotti outlet
ugg outlet store
ray-ban sunglasses
cheap oakley sunglasses
ugg boots sale
cheap uggs sale
louis vuitton purses
jordan 11s
oakley sunglasses wholesale
uggs for chea
louis vuitton handbags
the north face jackets
prada
tods outlet store
louis vuitton outlet stores
hollister clothing
abercrombie
michael kors outlet
cheap toms shoes
gucci handbags
kids lebron shoes
uggs on sale
north face jackets
air max 95
coach factory outlet
rolex watches
uggs on sale
official coach factory outlet
abercrombie
louis vuitton outlet stores

12/22/2015 8:19 PM  
Blogger chenlili said...

2016-5-5 xiaobao
tory burch outlet
cheap jordans
lebron james shoes 13
ed hardy clothing
michael kors outlet
louis vuitton bags
asics shoes
ralph lauren outlet
christian louboutin sale
jordans for sale
replica watches
coach outlet
ray ban wayfarer
ray ban sunglasses
nike free run
toms
ray ban sunglasses
louis vuitton outlet
kobe shoes 11
jeremy scott shoes
kobe bryant shoes
louis vuitton
nike basketball shoes
tiffany outlet
coach factory outlet
cheap oakleys
juicy couture
nike roshe run
louis vuitton outlet
coach outlet online
mont blanc pens
gucci handbags
christian louboutin outlet
michael kors outlet
burberry outlet
michael kors outlet
ray ban sunglasses
christian louboutin outlet
jordans
louis vuitton handbags

5/05/2016 12:13 AM  
Blogger Gege Dai said...

salomon shoes
cheap nike shoes
giuseppe zanotti outlet
nike air max uk
ed hardy tshirts
oakland raiders jersey
chicago bulls
nike roshe run
new balance shoes
air max 90
golden state warriors jersey
titans jersey
baltimore ravens jerseys
philadelphia eagles jersey
abercrombie outlet
polo pas cher
san francisco 49ers jerseys
los angeles clippers
oakland raiders jerseys
atlanta falcons jersey
chicago blackhawks jerseys
vans shoes
dallas cowboys jersey
tods shoes sale
oklahoma city thunder
nike free running
kansas city chiefs jerseys
supra shoes sale
new orleans saints jersey
boston celtics jerseys
air max 2014
oklahoma city thunder jerseys
lacoste pas cher
hollister
cheap nike shoes sale
linyuan0514

5/14/2016 4:05 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home