Saturday, February 11, 2006

Two Hundred Years of Reliance on Foreign Authority

Steven Calabresi and Stephanie Dotson Zimdahl have recently published in William & Mary Law Review an article on The Supreme Court and Foreign Sources of Law: Two Hundred Years Of Practice and the Juvenile Death Penalty Decision available at 47 William & Mary L. Rev. 743. An earlier version is available on SSRN here.

Here is the summary from their introduction:
Our analysis of the Court's practice leads us to several conclusions. First, we believe that those political and journalistic commentators who say that the Court has never before cited or relied uponforeign law are clearly and demonstrably wrong. In fact, the Court has relied on such sources to some extent throughout its history. Second, the Court has cited foreign law with much more frequency in far more important constitutional cases as the Court has grown older and has increased significantly its use of such sources in striking down legislation only since Trop v. Dulles in 1958. The phenomenon that Justice Scalia complains about is thus a relatively new development. Third, the Court has tended to cite foreign law in some of its most problematic opinions, such as several of the concurring opinions in Dred Scott, and its opinions in Reynolds and in Roe v. Wade. This suggests that Justice Scalia is right to be wary of the Court's movement in this direction. Fourth, the historical evidence suggests to us that citation of foreign law is most (if at all) justifiable when the U.S. Constitution asks the Justices to weigh whether a certain practice is reasonable, as it does in the Fourth Amendment, or whether it is unusual, as it does in the Eighth Amendment. In contrast, citing foreign law is least justifiable when the Court is asked to determine whether an unenumerated right is deeply rooted in American history and tradition, as was the case in Lawrence, or whether a federal statute violates historically unique American federalism rules, as it was asked to do in Printz v. United States. We suggest that in the overwhelming majority of non-Fourth and non-Eighth Amendment cases, it is inappropriate for the Court to cite foreign law. Citation of such law can, in fact, be a sign that the Court is falling into policymaking, as it did in Dred Scott, Reynolds, and Roe, and this, in turn, suggests that the Justices are behaving illegitimately. We thus substantially agree with the spirit, if not entirely all of the substance, of Justice Scalia's warning against citing foreign law in most U.S. constitutional cases.

3 Comments:

Blogger jennylyn said...

I am not so exposed in the laws of the land, I just know my rights. For those who are into these laws they might as well polish things up to come up.

Jennylyn from pneus hiver 

1/26/2012 5:55 AM  
Blogger Meredith Andrews said...

Nick’s brother is a saint. And Nick can’t help hating him for itNice car,” said Nick’s brother Ed, as they put the bags Mabinogi Gold in the boot at the airport. Nick looked up at him, wondering if Ed meant anything more than this, and then decided that he did not. He would have to try not to be so touchy. They had not seen each other for nearly two years and his brother was simply making an effort. After all, it was a Mabinogi Gold nice car, a black four-wheel drive Toyota, but hardly ostentatious. It was the first substantial thing Nick had bought when he and Beth had moved to the US eighteen months before, and he could not pretend he did not enjoy sitting up high behind the wheel, driving the Mabinogi Gold wide sunny streets on the way to work every day.

8/08/2013 5:09 AM  
Blogger Meredith Andrews said...

Bustone, and his homosexual partner Kikki Rodriguez, had MapleStory Mesos been admitted for emergency treatment after a felching session had gone seriously wrong. "I pushed the cardboard tube up his rectum and slippedFaggot, our gerbil, in," he explained. "As usual, Kikki shouted"Armageddon," my cue that he'd had enough. I tried MapleStory mesos to retrieve Faggot but he wouldn't come out again, so I peered into the tube and struck a match, thinking the light might attract him." At a hushed press conference, a hospital spokesman described what had happened next. "The flame ignited a pocket of intestinal gas and a flame shot up the tube igniting Mr. Bustone's moustache and severely burning his face. It also set fire to the gerbil's fur and whiskers MapleStory Mesos which, in turn, ignited a larger pocket of gas further up the intestine propelling the rodent out like a cannonball."

8/08/2013 5:10 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home